The Hard Thing About Hard Things
Tags: #business #entrepreneurship #leadership #management #startups #technology #culture
Authors: Ben Horowitz
_thumbnail.jpg)
Overview
This book shares my personal experiences and hard-earned lessons from building and running technology companies. I don’t offer simple recipes or formulas, because there are no easy answers when it comes to the tough challenges that entrepreneurs and CEOs face. Instead, I aim to provide practical insights, guidance, and inspiration for navigating the complexities, uncertainties, and emotional rollercoaster of building something from nothing. I cover a wide range of topics, including dealing with setbacks and failures, building and managing teams, making difficult decisions, fostering a strong company culture, and maintaining your own sanity amidst the chaos. I emphasize the importance of transparency, trust, and open communication within an organization, and I offer specific techniques and strategies for hiring, firing, motivating, and leading people effectively. Ultimately, this book is a guide for those who are willing to embrace the struggle, to face their fears, and to make the hard decisions required to build something great.
Book Outline
4. Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart
In the unpredictable world of technology startups, there’s always a move to be made, even when things seem hopeless. Don’t get bogged down in conventional thinking or be paralyzed by seemingly insurmountable challenges. Embrace a strategic mindset, think outside the box, and adapt your approach to navigate the complexities and find innovative solutions. Remember, circumstances can change rapidly, and what appears impossible today might become the breakthrough of tomorrow.
Key concept: “This is not checkers; this is motherfuckin’ chess.”
4. Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart
When facing difficult situations, particularly those requiring course correction, it’s crucial to be decisive and take full responsibility. Don’t try to sugarcoat the situation or minimize the impact. Address the issue head-on, acknowledge the failures, and be transparent about the necessary steps to move forward. It’s better to rip the band-aid off quickly and absorb the pain than to prolong the suffering and erode trust.
Key concept: “If you are going to eat shit, don’t nibble.”
4. Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart
Layoffs are an unfortunate but sometimes necessary part of running a business. When conducting layoffs, the focus should be on the people who are remaining with the company. Treat those who are leaving with respect and dignity, but prioritize the well-being and morale of those who will be responsible for carrying the company forward. Their perception of how you handle the situation will heavily influence their trust and commitment in the future.
Key concept: “The message is for the people who are staying.”
4. Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart
Layoffs should be conducted by the direct managers of the affected employees, not by HR or a third party. This is essential to maintain trust and accountability. Managers must be willing to face the difficult task of letting go of their own people, demonstrating empathy, clarity, and support during the process. Outsourcing this responsibility undermines the manager-employee relationship and can damage the company’s reputation.
Key concept: “Managers must lay off their own people.”
5. Chapter 5: Take Care of the People, the Products, and the Profits—in That Order
Building a successful company starts with prioritizing your people. Create a work environment where employees feel valued, motivated, and empowered to contribute their best work. A great product is essential, but it’s the people who design, build, and market it that make the difference. Profits will naturally follow when you have a talented and engaged team focused on building a great product.
Key concept: “Take care of the people, the products, and the profits—in that order.”
5. Chapter 5: Take Care of the People, the Products, and the Profits—in That Order
Transparency and clear communication are essential for building trust within an organization. When trust is high, less communication is needed because employees believe in the company’s direction and in each other’s intentions. Conversely, when trust is low, even extensive communication may fail to bridge the gap. Building a culture of trust requires open and honest dialogue, consistent actions, and a willingness to address issues head-on.
Key concept: “In any human interaction, the required amount of communication is inversely proportional to the level of trust.”
5. Chapter 5: Take Care of the People, the Products, and the Profits—in That Order
Hiring talent away from your friends’ companies can be tempting, but it often comes at the cost of damaging those relationships. If you would consider it a serious breach of trust for someone to hire multiple employees from your company, then you should hold yourself to the same standard. Establish clear policies regarding hiring from specific companies and prioritize maintaining strong relationships within your network.
Key concept: “The Reflexive Principle of Employee Raiding”: “If you would be shocked and horrified if Company X hired several of your employees, then you should not hire any of theirs.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
Companies often promote employees until they reach a level where they can no longer perform effectively. This is unavoidable because there’s no way to know in advance at what level an employee will become incompetent. Therefore, it’s crucial to have a rigorous promotion process that clearly defines the required skills for each level and evaluates candidates against those specific skills. This helps to ensure that promotions are based on merit and that employees are not promoted beyond their capabilities.
Key concept: “The Peter Principle holds that in a hierarchy, members are promoted so long as they work competently. Sooner or later they are promoted to a position at which they are no longer competent (their “level of incompetence”), and there they remain being unable to earn further promotions.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
This law highlights the importance of carefully managing titles and promotions to avoid a downward spiral in talent quality. When a low-performing individual holds a certain title, it sets a low bar for others at that level and can discourage high-performing individuals from seeking promotions. To combat this, companies should establish clear performance standards, conduct regular performance reviews, and promote based on merit rather than tenure or political maneuvering.
Key concept: “The Law of Crappy People states: For any title level in a large organization, the talent on that level will eventually converge to the crappiest person with the title.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
While it might seem efficient to only focus on solutions, this management maxim can discourage employees from raising important issues that they cannot solve themselves. A CEO needs to be aware of all the problems facing the company, even those without readily available solutions. Create a culture that rewards employees for bringing problems to light, even without solutions, and encourage open dialogue to address those issues collectively.
Key concept: “Don’t bring me a problem without bringing me a solution.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
Building a startup is an emotional rollercoaster. There will be times of great excitement and optimism, and there will be times of intense fear and uncertainty. Don’t be surprised by the intensity of these emotions; they are part of the journey. The key is to maintain a balance between acknowledging the challenges and maintaining the belief that you can overcome them.
Key concept: “You only ever experience two emotions: euphoria and terror. And I find that lack of sleep enhances them both.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
Ambition should be directed towards company success. Managers, especially, should prioritize the overall goals of the organization over their own personal ambitions. If the company fails to achieve its objectives, then individual success becomes irrelevant. Encourage a culture where employees are aligned on the company’s mission and where personal success is seen as a byproduct of collective achievements.
Key concept: “Two percent of zero is zero.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
Sometimes the most effective strategies are found by focusing on what you’re not doing. By identifying activities or areas that are being neglected, you can uncover hidden opportunities and prioritize efforts more effectively. Regularly ask yourself, ‘What am I not doing that could be valuable?’ and explore those areas to identify potential growth avenues or areas for improvement.
Key concept: “Note to self: It’s a good idea to ask, ‘What am I not doing?’ ”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
When things go wrong, it’s easy to look for external factors to blame. However, as CEO, you are ultimately responsible for everything that happens in your company. Don’t waste time making excuses or blaming others. Focus on identifying the root causes of the problems, taking ownership, and driving solutions.
Key concept: “You can’t blame Jazz musicians or David Stern with his NBA fashion issues.”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
Training should be a core responsibility of managers at all levels, and especially for CEOs. While it may seem like a time-consuming task, training is one of the highest leverage activities a manager can perform. By investing in developing your employees’ skills and knowledge, you can significantly improve their performance, increase productivity, and create a more engaged and loyal workforce. Don’t delegate training to others; take ownership and make it a priority.
Key concept: “Why Training Is the Boss’s Job”
6. Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern
Don’t prejudge an employee’s ability to scale based on limited information or assumptions. It’s impossible to know for certain how someone will perform at a larger scale until they are actually in that role. Instead of making premature judgments, focus on evaluating your team based on their current performance, their ability to learn and adapt, and their commitment to the company’s mission. Provide opportunities for growth and development, and trust your employees to rise to the occasion when the time comes.
Key concept: “Predicting whether an executive can scale corrupts your ability to manage, is unfair, and doesn’t work.”
7. Chapter 7: How to Lead Even When You Don’t Know Where You Are Going
Creating a positive and productive work environment requires clear communication, well-defined roles, and streamlined processes. When employees understand their responsibilities and have the tools and support they need to succeed, they can focus on doing their best work. In contrast, poorly run organizations often suffer from organizational boundaries, conflicting priorities, and a lack of clarity, leading to frustration and decreased productivity.
Key concept: “In good organizations, people can focus on their work and have confidence that if they get their work done, good things will happen for both the company and them personally.”
7. Chapter 7: How to Lead Even When You Don’t Know Where You Are Going
Different management styles are required for different phases of a company’s lifecycle. In peacetime, the focus is on maximizing existing opportunities, fostering creativity, and expanding the market. In wartime, the priority is survival, requiring laser focus on the mission, strict adherence to the plan, and a willingness to make tough decisions. Knowing when to adopt a peacetime or wartime mindset is essential for navigating the challenges of building a successful company.
Key concept: Peacetime CEO/Wartime CEO
7. Chapter 7: How to Lead Even When You Don’t Know Where You Are Going
When facing challenges, it’s important to remember that nobody cares about your excuses or justifications for failure. Your investors, your board, your employees, and even your family ultimately care about results. Don’t dwell on what you could have done or blame external factors. Focus on what you can control, make the best decisions with the information you have, and execute relentlessly. In the end, nobody cares about the reasons for failure; they care about success.
Key concept: “Bill, nobody cares, just coach your team.”
7. Chapter 7: How to Lead Even When You Don’t Know Where You Are Going
Even when firing an executive, it’s crucial to treat them with dignity and respect. While you may need to terminate their employment, you can still acknowledge their contributions, provide support during the transition, and allow them to maintain their professional reputation. Handling difficult situations with grace and empathy reflects well on you as a leader and helps to maintain a positive culture within the organization.
Key concept: “Ben, you cannot let him keep his job, but you absolutely can let him keep his respect.”
7. Chapter 7: How to Lead Even When You Don’t Know Where You Are Going
In high-stakes negotiations, sometimes you have to get creative and push the boundaries to achieve a successful outcome. Setting artificial deadlines, leveraging competition, and employing strategic tactics can help you gain an advantage and drive the deal towards closure. However, it’s important to operate within ethical boundaries and avoid compromising your integrity or reputation.
Key concept: “Gentlemen, I’ve done many deals in my lifetime and through that process, I’ve developed a methodology, a way of doing things, a philosophy if you will. Within that philosophy, I have certain beliefs. I believe in artificial deadlines. I believe in playing one against the other. I believe in doing everything and anything short of illegal or immoral to get the damned deal done.”
Essential Questions
1. What is the most difficult skill for a CEO to master, and why?
Horowitz argues that being a CEO is an ‘unnatural job’ because it requires making difficult decisions with incomplete information, often facing opposition from trusted advisors and employees. He emphasizes the importance of courage and conviction in such situations, as the CEO’s superior knowledge of the company’s context must guide the decision-making process, even in the face of uncertainty and potential unpopularity.
2. Why is it important to build a ‘good company,’ and how does it impact a company’s ability to navigate challenging times?
Building a ‘good company’ where employees are empowered, motivated, and aligned with the mission is crucial for long-term success. It becomes even more critical during tough times when external factors like market downturns or competition intensify. A positive work environment fosters loyalty, encourages creativity and innovation, and helps to retain top talent, ultimately increasing the chances of survival and long-term success.
3. What is the role of transparency in building a strong company culture, and how does it affect communication and decision-making?
Horowitz advocates for radical transparency within an organization. He believes in openly discussing problems, encouraging employees to share bad news, and fostering a culture where mistakes are seen as learning opportunities. This approach builds trust, allows for more effective problem-solving through collective intelligence, and helps to prevent small issues from festering into major crises. He acknowledges that this level of transparency can be uncomfortable, but argues that it is essential for building a high-performing, resilient organization.
4. What is the ‘scale anticipation fallacy,’ and how can it lead to poor hiring decisions?
Horowitz argues that while hiring experienced executives can be beneficial, it’s crucial to avoid falling into the ‘scale anticipation fallacy.’ Prematurely judging an employee’s ability to scale can hinder their development and lead to poor hiring decisions. Instead, focus on evaluating candidates based on their current performance and their capacity to learn and adapt. Provide clear expectations, opportunities for growth, and trust your team to develop the skills necessary to scale when the time comes.
5. What are the challenges and best practices for integrating ‘old people,’ or experienced executives, into a startup culture?
Horowitz highlights the inherent tension between maintaining a founder-led culture and bringing in experienced executives who often have different management styles and expectations. He stresses the importance of clear cultural guidelines, rigorous performance standards, and open communication to ensure that senior hires integrate effectively and contribute to rather than detract from the company’s unique identity and values.
Key Takeaways
1. Embrace Radical Transparency
Transparency and open communication are fundamental for building trust and fostering a strong company culture. Sharing both good and bad news openly allows for collective problem-solving and prevents minor issues from escalating into major crises. A CEO who embraces transparency demonstrates vulnerability and authenticity, which in turn encourages employees to be more open and honest in their communication. This creates a more collaborative and effective work environment.
Practical Application:
An AI product engineer leading a team developing a new language model could apply this by openly acknowledging the technical challenges and limitations of the current model, encouraging the team to share their concerns and ideas for improvement, and fostering a collaborative approach to finding solutions. This transparency builds trust, motivates the team to strive for excellence, and allows for faster iteration and progress.
2. Avoid Generic Solutions
There are no one-size-fits-all solutions in the fast-paced world of technology. Understanding the specific needs of your company and customers is crucial for developing the right products and strategies. Generic solutions often fail to address the unique challenges and nuances of a particular market. Instead of aiming for broad applicability, focus on delivering superior value to a specific target audience, even if it means sacrificing broader appeal.
Practical Application:
An AI product engineer could apply this principle when building a large language model. Instead of aiming for a generic, all-encompassing model, they could focus on developing a model specifically tailored for a particular industry or application, such as healthcare, finance, or customer service. This targeted approach allows for deeper domain expertise, more efficient training, and ultimately a more valuable and impactful product.
3. Prioritize Innovation over Existing Requirements
Don’t be afraid to challenge conventional wisdom and pursue innovative solutions, even if they go against existing requirements or data. Customers often only know what they want based on their experience with current products, but it’s the innovator’s job to envision what’s possible and to push the boundaries of what’s currently available. This requires a combination of knowledge, skill, and courage to challenge assumptions and explore new possibilities.
Practical Application:
When faced with a choice between developing a new feature for an AI product based on existing customer requests versus pursuing a potentially more innovative but less certain approach, an AI product engineer should carefully consider the long-term implications. Sticking with known requirements may seem safe, but it can lead to incremental improvements rather than breakthrough innovations. Embracing the unknown and taking calculated risks is often necessary to achieve significant advancements and differentiate your product in a competitive market.
4. Embrace the Struggle
Building a company is an emotional rollercoaster, filled with highs and lows. It’s crucial to develop the resilience and mental fortitude to navigate the inevitable setbacks and challenges. Don’t let negative emotions paralyze you or lead to poor decision-making. Acknowledge the difficulties, learn from them, and move forward with renewed determination.
Practical Application:
When faced with a setback, such as a failed product launch or a missed revenue target, an AI product engineer should avoid dwelling on the negative emotions and instead focus on analyzing the situation objectively. By identifying the root causes of the problem, learning from the mistakes, and developing a plan for improvement, the engineer can turn the setback into a valuable learning opportunity and emerge stronger and more prepared for future challenges.
Suggested Deep Dive
Chapter: Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart
This chapter focuses on dealing with setbacks, making difficult decisions, and maintaining your own sanity as a leader. It offers practical advice on handling layoffs, managing your emotions, and developing the courage to make tough calls, which is essential for any AI product engineer leading a team or product development.
Memorable Quotes
Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart. 57
“But I don’t believe in statistics. I believe in calculus.”
Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart. 61
“This is not checkers; this is motherfuckin’ chess.”
Chapter 4: When Things Fall Apart. 85
“Nobody cares.”
Chapter 6: Concerning the Going Concern. 144
“Two percent of zero is zero.”
Chapter 7: How to Lead Even When You Don’t Know Where You Are Going. 179
“Investing in courage and determination was an easy decision for me.”
Comparative Analysis
“The Hard Thing About Hard Things” stands out in the business literature for its raw honesty and focus on the psychological challenges of leadership. Unlike many books that offer idealized frameworks and success stories, this book delves into the messy reality of building and running a company, acknowledging the struggles, doubts, and difficult decisions that come with the territory. While other notable works like “Good to Great” by Jim Collins focus on identifying patterns of success, Horowitz emphasizes the importance of adapting to ever-changing circumstances and making tough calls even with limited information. He shares specific anecdotes and personal experiences, making his insights both relatable and actionable. However, while Horowitz stresses the importance of building a strong company culture, his emphasis on profanity and aggressive management tactics may not resonate with everyone and could be misconstrued without careful context.
Reflection
“The Hard Thing About Hard Things” is a valuable contribution to business literature, offering a candid and insightful perspective on the realities of leadership. Horowitz’s personal experiences and willingness to share his struggles, doubts, and mistakes make the book relatable and engaging. His focus on the psychological aspects of being a CEO, a topic often neglected in management books, provides valuable insights into the mental fortitude required to navigate the challenges of building and running a company. However, readers should approach his advice with a critical lens. While his emphasis on transparency and accountability is generally sound, his endorsement of aggressive management tactics and profanity-laden communication may not be suitable for all organizations. Additionally, his experiences, while insightful, may not be universally applicable, as the specific challenges and contexts of startups can vary widely. Overall, “The Hard Thing About Hard Things” is a compelling read for aspiring entrepreneurs and seasoned CEOs alike, offering practical wisdom and a dose of tough love for those willing to embrace the struggle and strive for greatness.
Flashcards
What is the secret to being a successful CEO, according to Ben Horowitz?
The ability to focus and make the best move when there are no good moves. It’s the moment where you feel most like hiding or dying that you can make the biggest difference.
What is the relationship between trust and communication?
In any human interaction, the required amount of communication is inversely proportional to the level of trust.
How does a healthy company culture handle bad news?
A good culture is like the old RIP routing protocol: Bad news travels fast; good news travels slow.
When can you make the biggest difference as a CEO?
It’s the moments where you feel most like hiding or dying that you can make the biggest difference as a CEO.
What is the most important rule of raising money privately?
Look for a market of one. You only need one investor to say yes, so it’s best to ignore the other thirty who say ‘no.’
What is the relationship between struggle and failure?
The struggle is not failure, but it causes failure. Especially if you are weak. Always if you are weak.
What are the two emotions you experience in a startup?
You only ever experience two emotions: euphoria and terror. And I find that lack of sleep enhances them both.
What is the biggest lesson Ben Horowitz learned regarding company culture?
CEOs should tell it like it is. Be radically transparent with your team.