Back to index

Expecting Better

Tags: #parenting #pregnancy #data analysis #health #decision-making

Authors: Emily Oster

Overview

In Expecting Better, I tackle common pregnancy anxieties by dissecting the data behind established recommendations and widespread beliefs. Using the tools of an economist, I critically analyze medical research to uncover the real risks and benefits associated with various pregnancy choices, allowing women to make informed decisions based on their individual needs and preferences. I expose the flaws in many common assumptions about pregnancy, such as the idea that a woman’s fertility plummets at age 35, that any amount of alcohol is harmful, or that bed rest is an effective treatment for preterm labor. I also highlight the importance of carefully evaluating evidence, recognizing that studies vary in quality and that correlation does not equal causation. Ultimately, my goal is to empower expectant mothers to take control of their pregnancies, ditch the guilt and unnecessary anxieties, and make informed choices that are right for them and their families.

Book Outline

1. Prep Work

Contrary to popular belief, a woman’s fertility doesn’t plummet off a cliff at age 35. While fertility does gradually decline with age, research suggests the decline is not as dramatic as many fear, with the most significant drop occurring after 40.

Key concept: Thirty is not actually old in pregnancy terms. “Advanced maternal age” is reserved for women over 35, and you wouldn’t be faulted for thinking that 35 was a sharp cutoff. I read one paper once that referred to eggs as “best used by 35.”

2. Data-Driven Conception

Successfully conceiving depends heavily on timing intercourse to coincide with ovulation. The optimal window for conception spans from five days before ovulation through the day of ovulation itself. Although it’s possible to conceive outside this window, the probability significantly decreases. Various methods, including temperature charting, cervical mucus monitoring, and ovulation predictor kits, can help pinpoint ovulation.

Key concept: The key to pregnancy is that when the egg starts making its way down the tube, the sperm has to be waiting for it.

3. The Two-Week Wait

The two-week wait, the time between ovulation and a missed period, often triggers anxiety and restrictive behaviors. However, during this early stage, the developing embryo is a mass of undifferentiated cells. If some cells are damaged, others can replace them without impacting the baby. Only excessive harm, enough to prevent the embryo from developing, is cause for concern.

Key concept: The quick answer is that, assuming you did conceive, your behavior during those 2 weeks would have no impact on your baby.

4. The Vices: Caffeine, Alcohol, and Tobacco

Official recommendations regarding alcohol and caffeine consumption during pregnancy are often overly cautious and lack nuance. While excessive alcohol consumption (binge drinking) is undoubtedly harmful, light drinking, such as a glass of wine per day, shows no credible evidence of negative effects on a child’s development. Similarly, moderate caffeine consumption, up to 3 or 4 cups of coffee per day, appears safe and doesn’t increase miscarriage risk.

Key concept: In moderation, pregnant women should feel comfortable with both alcohol and caffeine.

5. Miscarriage Fears

Miscarriage, a common fear during pregnancy, is most prevalent in the first trimester. While the chance of miscarriage steadily decreases as the pregnancy progresses, it’s helpful to understand the actual risks involved. The overall risk is around 10-15% for pregnancies developing normally at 6 weeks, dropping significantly to 1-2% by 11 or 12 weeks. Age and prior miscarriages increase the risk.

Key concept: If you are seen at 6 weeks and things look normal, what is the overall chance that you will have a miscarriage? The data suggests about 11 percent.

6. Beware of Deli Meats!

Many food restrictions during pregnancy seem arbitrary and overly cautious. While concerns about food contamination are valid, it’s important to differentiate between foods that are generally unsafe (raw poultry) and those that pose a slightly elevated risk during pregnancy (deli meats, sushi). Understanding the specific bacteria and parasites, their sources, and their potential impact on the pregnancy can empower women to make informed decisions based on their individual risk tolerance.

Key concept: The vast majority of pregnancy food restrictions arise from concerns about food contamination.

7. Nausea and My Mother-in-law

Nausea, a common and often debilitating symptom of early pregnancy, is actually a positive indicator. Women who experience nausea are less likely to miscarry. While medication is available to alleviate severe nausea, simpler remedies like ginger ale, vitamin B6, and small meals are often effective.

Key concept: As unpleasant as it is, nausea is a sign of a healthy pregnancy. Miscarriage rates are much lower for women who are nauseated than for those who are not.

8. Prenatal Screening and Testing

Prenatal screening and testing can help identify potential chromosomal abnormalities, like Down syndrome. There are two primary options: non-invasive screening, which analyzes blood or ultrasound data, and invasive testing, such as amniocentesis or CVS, which carries a small risk of miscarriage but offers definitive results. Non-invasive cell-free fetal DNA testing is highly accurate, detecting about 99% of Down syndrome cases with a low false-positive rate, while the older combined ultrasound and blood test is less accurate. Invasive testing procedures like amniocentesis and CVS carry a small risk of miscarriage but offer definitive diagnoses. The best choice depends on individual risk tolerance and preference for information.

Key concept: Cell-free fetal DNA testing (MaterniT21, Harmony, and others) are very accurate and can detect about 99 percent of Down syndrome cases.

9. The Surprising Perils of Gardening

Many common pregnancy concerns, such as those surrounding cat litter and gardening, are often overblown. While toxoplasmosis, a parasitic infection that can be transmitted through cat feces, poses a risk to pregnant women, the likelihood of contracting it from an older cat, especially an indoor cat, is extremely low. Gardening, however, poses a greater risk due to potential exposure to toxoplasmosis from soil. Hair dye, hot tubs, airplane travel, and moderate exercise are generally considered safe during pregnancy, with some specific caveats and recommendations.

Key concept: The worry about cat litter is toxoplasmosis… If your cat is old, regardless of whether it lives outside, it probably has already had this.

10. Eating for Two? You Wish

Excessive focus on pregnancy weight gain, while understandable, can be unnecessarily stressful. While gaining too little weight can lead to a smaller baby and potential complications, gaining slightly over the recommended amount is generally not a major concern. Research suggests that the impact of maternal weight gain on a child’s later weight is minimal, and the focus should be on overall healthy eating habits.

Key concept: If you gain 10 pounds over the recommendation during pregnancy, you would increase your child’s expected BMI by about 0.13. If your child is 5 feet 6 inches, this is an increase in weight from 149 to 150 pounds.

11. Pink and Blue

The fetal heart rate, although frequently used for gender prediction, is not a reliable indicator. Studies have shown no significant difference between male and female fetal heart rates. There are accurate methods for gender determination, including genetic testing during CVS or amniocentesis, as well as ultrasound imaging during the second trimester. However, short of these medical interventions, there’s no scientific evidence supporting any method for pre-selecting a baby’s gender.

Key concept: Contrary to beliefs commonly held by many pregnant women and their families… there are no significant differences between male and female fetal heart rate during the first trimester.

12. Working Out and Resting Up

While regular exercise during pregnancy can contribute to slightly lower weight gain, the overall impact is generally small. More importantly, moderate exercise has not been linked to any negative outcomes for the baby, and in fact, women who exercise often experience healthier pregnancies overall.

Key concept: On average, women who were encouraged to exercise gained about 1.3 fewer pounds during their pregnancies than women who were not.

13. Drug Safety

Despite common concerns about drug use and sleep position during pregnancy, the evidence suggests a more relaxed approach is often warranted. While some prescription and over-the-counter sleep aids have been linked to minor risks, others, like Unisom, are considered safe. As for sleep position, while lying on the back can restrict blood flow in some women, most will naturally adjust to a comfortable and safe position, typically on their left side.

Key concept: Advising women to sleep or lie exclusively on the left side is not practical and is irrelevant to the vast majority of patients.

14. Premature Birth (and the Dangers of Bed Rest)

Preterm labor, a major concern for expectant mothers, is often met with the recommendation of bed rest. However, there’s no scientific evidence to support this practice, and it may even have negative consequences for both mother and baby. Factors that can positively impact preterm labor outcomes include access to high-quality neonatal intensive care units and the administration of steroids to accelerate fetal lung development.

Key concept: There is no evidence that bed rest will prevent preterm labor. Avoid it.

15. High-Risk Pregnancy

A high-risk pregnancy requires specialized care and attention from a medical professional. Treatments often vary significantly depending on the individual’s situation and the specific details of the pregnancy.

Key concept: If you end up with a high-risk-pregnancy condition, your doctor is going to be your best resource.

16. I’m Going to Be Pregnant Forever, Right?

The anxieties surrounding the potential for a prolonged pregnancy are often unfounded. While first-time mothers frequently go past their due date, with the vast majority of babies arriving within a week on either side, medical induction is virtually guaranteed by 42 weeks. Cervical checks, including assessment of dilation and effacement, can provide a clearer picture of labor progress and potential timing.

Key concept: The good news is that you will not be pregnant forever.

17. Labor Induction

Elective induction, while increasingly common, is not without its downsides, including increased pain and a higher chance of a C-section. It’s particularly important to avoid induction prior to the due date, as this can negatively impact a baby’s health.

Key concept: As is typical for me, as soon as I realized I didn’t want an induction, I got paranoid that it would be forced on me.

18. The Labor Numbers

Labor unfolds in three distinct stages: dilation, pushing, and delivery of the placenta. While this general framework is widely understood, the actual experience of labor can be highly variable and unpredictable. Understanding the normal range of dilation times and the potential for variations in labor progress can help manage expectations and reduce anxiety.

Key concept: This is a textbook description of labor – it’s what you’ll see in virtually every pregnancy book, and it’s what your doctor will tell you.

19. To Epidural or Not to Epidural?

The epidural, while highly effective in reducing labor pain, is associated with some risks and complications for the mother, including increased use of instruments during delivery, longer pushing times, and a slightly higher chance of needing a C-section. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to have an epidural is a personal one, weighing the benefits of pain relief against the potential drawbacks.

Key concept: If it works as it should, many women have virtually no pain during the dilation part of labor.

20. Beyond Pain Relief

Many pregnancy-related decisions, particularly those surrounding labor and delivery, often present women with a false dichotomy: embracing the “natural” approach or accepting the standard medical interventions. A thoughtful approach lies in evaluating the evidence and making informed choices aligned with individual values and preferences. A well-crafted birth plan, created in consultation with a healthcare provider, can guide these decisions.

Key concept: The world really seems to contain two groups: those who would like to avoid any medical interventions, and those who embrace whatever is the standard birth practice.

21. The Aftermath

The immediate postpartum period is marked by a flurry of decisions regarding newborn care. While practices like delayed cord clamping and Vitamin K shots are generally recommended, others, like the use of eye antibiotics, are more debatable. Research on cord blood banking suggests the potential benefits are currently limited, while public cord blood donation offers greater potential for wider impact.

Key concept: The whole process is a bit abrupt and overwhelming: all of a sudden there is another person there.

22. Home Birth: Progressive or Regressive? And Who Cleans the Tub?

Home birth, while appealing to some, carries increased risks compared to hospital births, especially for first-time mothers and high-risk pregnancies. While the potential for complications during labor is relatively low, access to medical interventions and emergency care in a hospital setting significantly reduces the risk of adverse outcomes. The decision of whether or not to have a home birth should involve careful consideration of individual circumstances, access to qualified medical care, and risk tolerance.

Key concept: To be direct about it: it’s true that women have been giving birth at home for millions of years, but a lot of them, and many more of their babies, died.

Essential Questions

1. How does age impact a woman’s fertility, and what are the implications for family planning?

A woman’s fertility gradually declines with age, with a more pronounced drop after 40. However, the decline is not as dramatic as many fear, and age 35 is not a hard cutoff. Focusing on overall health and well-being before pregnancy is more beneficial than stressing over age-related fertility anxieties.

2. Are there any safe levels of alcohol and caffeine consumption during pregnancy, and how can we evaluate the evidence on this topic?

While excessive alcohol consumption is harmful during pregnancy, moderate drinking, such as a glass of wine per day, shows no evidence of negatively impacting a child’s development. Similarly, moderate caffeine consumption, up to 3 or 4 cups of coffee per day, appears safe. It’s crucial to understand that blanket recommendations can be misleading, and making informed choices based on the actual data is key.

3. What is the actual risk of miscarriage throughout pregnancy, and how can understanding this information help manage anxiety?

While miscarriage is a common fear, it’s important to understand that it’s most prevalent in the first trimester and the risk significantly decreases as the pregnancy progresses. Various factors, including age and previous miscarriages, can influence the risk. Access to accurate information about miscarriage rates empowers women to manage their anxieties and make informed decisions about early pregnancy testing.

4. What are the real risks associated with various food restrictions during pregnancy, and how can we make informed decisions about food safety?

Many food restrictions during pregnancy are based on concerns about food contamination, but the level of risk varies greatly depending on the specific food and bacteria involved. Understanding the actual risks, rather than relying on blanket bans, allows women to make informed decisions based on their individual risk tolerance.

5. What are the pros and cons of home births, and under what circumstances might it be a viable option?

Home births, while appealing for some, carry increased risks compared to hospital births, especially for first-time mothers and high-risk pregnancies. The availability of medical interventions and emergency care in a hospital significantly reduces the chances of adverse outcomes. Choosing a qualified and experienced midwife is crucial for ensuring safety during a home birth, though it doesn’t eliminate the inherent risks.

Key Takeaways

1. Data-driven decision-making is crucial during pregnancy.

Throughout the book, I emphasize the importance of looking at reliable data and research to make informed choices during pregnancy. Anecdotes and personal experiences, while common, are often misleading and unreliable in drawing accurate conclusions.

Practical Application:

In AI development, this translates to focusing on data-driven insights rather than anecdotal feedback when making product decisions. For instance, relying on comprehensive user data analysis for feature prioritization instead of isolated user complaints can lead to better product outcomes.

2. Pregnancy decisions should be individualized and based on personal preferences and risk tolerance.

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to pregnancy. Every woman and every pregnancy is unique. What’s right for one person might not be right for another. This book encourages women to understand the data, weigh the risks and benefits, and make choices that feel right for them, in consultation with their doctor.

Practical Application:

When designing an AI product, this translates to empowering users with control and choices. Allowing for customization, user preferences, and various levels of interaction can improve user satisfaction and engagement. Just like there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to pregnancy, there isn’t one for AI interaction either.

3. Expectant mothers should challenge blanket recommendations and seek out evidence-based information to make informed decisions.

Many pregnancy recommendations are unnecessarily restrictive and anxiety-inducing. By understanding the actual risks and benefits involved, women can make more informed and empowered choices. This includes questioning common beliefs and seeking out reliable information to make decisions that feel right for them and their families.

Practical Application:

This applies to AI transparency and ethical considerations as well. Developers should strive for clear communication about data usage, algorithmic biases, and potential impacts of AI systems, allowing users to make informed decisions about their interaction with the technology.

Suggested Deep Dive

Chapter: Chapter 8: Prenatal Screening and Testing

This chapter provides a deep dive into the complex world of prenatal screening and testing, offering a clear explanation of the different options, their accuracy, and the associated risks. This knowledge is crucial for expectant mothers to make informed decisions about genetic testing, and it directly relates to the development of AI-powered tools that could improve the accuracy and accessibility of prenatal diagnosis.

Memorable Quotes

Introduction. 20

The tools of economics turn out to be enormously useful in evaluating the quality of information in any situation. Everywhere. And that includes the womb.

The Two-Week Wait. 43

Early pregnancy tests can detect a pregnancy 4 or even 5 days before your missed period, but pregnancy loss is common in this period.

The Vices. 55

In moderation, pregnant women should feel comfortable with both alcohol and caffeine.

Caffeine. 74

The bottom line is that the evidence overwhelmingly shows that light drinking is fine.

Bed Rest. 176

There is no evidence that bed rest will prevent preterm labor. Avoid it.

Comparative Analysis

“Expecting Better” stands out in the pregnancy literature for its rigorous, data-driven approach. Unlike many books that rely on anecdotal evidence or outdated research, Oster delves into the medical literature, critically analyzing studies to uncover the real risks and benefits associated with various pregnancy choices. This approach aligns with books like “Your Medical Mind: How to Decide What Is Right for You” by Jerome Groopman and Pamela Hartzband, which advocate for patient empowerment and informed decision-making in healthcare. However, Oster goes a step further by providing concrete data and statistical analysis, making her recommendations more tangible and less subject to individual interpretation. While some may critique her reliance on observational studies, which can be prone to biases, her meticulous analysis and focus on high-quality research mitigate these concerns. Furthermore, her emphasis on individualized decision-making, acknowledging that “one size fits all” recommendations are rarely appropriate in pregnancy, distinguishes her work from many other books in the field.

Reflection

Expecting Better provides a refreshing perspective on pregnancy, challenging the often fear-mongering and arbitrary recommendations that pervade the experience. By encouraging women to analyze the data and make informed choices, the book empowers them to take ownership of their pregnancies. While Oster’s background as an economist might raise skepticism about her authority on medical matters, her meticulous research and collaboration with medical professionals lend credibility to her conclusions. However, it’s crucial to acknowledge that individual circumstances vary, and what’s right for one woman might not be right for another. This underscores the importance of open communication with a trusted healthcare provider and personal risk assessment. The book’s central message of empowering women with information and encouraging them to trust their own judgment, resonates strongly, making it a valuable resource for expectant mothers seeking a more informed and less stressful pregnancy experience.

Flashcards

What is considered a safe level of alcohol consumption during pregnancy?

Up to 1 drink a day in the second and third trimesters, 1-2 drinks a week in the first trimester.

How many cups of coffee can a pregnant woman safely consume daily?

Up to 3-4 cups per day.

Is bed rest an effective way to prevent preterm labor?

No evidence supports it, and it may have negative consequences.

What is the most accurate non-invasive prenatal screening test?

Cell-free fetal DNA testing, like MaterniT21 and Harmony.

What is the approximate risk of miscarriage from an amniocentesis?

Around 1 in 800

Why is Pitocin often given after birth?

It dramatically reduces the risk of postpartum hemorrhage.

How does a baby develop during the 2-week wait, and what are the implications for potential risks?

A mass of undifferentiated cells. Damage to some cells can be compensated for by other cells without harming the developing baby.

Is nausea during pregnancy a good or bad sign?

Nausea is associated with lower miscarriage rates and is generally considered a positive sign.